It’s Not Like It Was Before
My ten-year high school reunion is next summer and I’m preparing a little toast for the occasion. I wonder if there’s a time limit….
———-
As most of you know, I was a prodigiously well-behaved student. There were a few exceptions, like the time in Mrs. LaTorre’s fifth grade class when I led you, my classmates, in a spirited chorus of Kill LaWhore! Kill LaWhore! from my post atop the jungle gym. You followed my command as if I weren’t just your classmate but a sixth grader or even a hall monitor. I was subsequently forced to get a Behavior Book, wherein Mrs. LaTorre marked my behavior each afternoon with a smiley face on a good day, a middle finger on a bad one. I then had to take this book to Mazog and Pazog, both of whom agreed that LaWhore was an appropriate term and that the bitch should stop stifling my creative expression. The disgrace of the Behavior Book was exacerbated every afternoon when Mrs. LaTorre announced, Will Katie Herzog, the only fifth grader who needs a Behavior Book, please come to my desk so I can see if Mazog and Pazog signed aforementioned Behavior Book, which burned my eyes like that time Scott Williams jumped me from the slide and threw his jock strap over my head. (Heard about those child pornography charges, Scott. God damn, that makes me feel like I can predict the future.)
But, still, I was a pretty good kid. I got kicked off of a few athletic teams (Hey there, Coach Barnes! I can see that gin blossom from here!) and was suspended for selling hemp necklaces to those of you who spent your Taco Bell wages on tickets to Phish shows because Principal O’Neal (RIP) didn’t believe me when I said, Look, brah. You’d have to smoke a doobs the size of a telephone pole to get babycakes off this shit. You dig? Oh, and there was the ninth grade talent show when my band Broken Hearts, Broken Hymons, a dub project influenced by early Billy Joel and psychotropics, was booed off stage after the opening lines of our single, Ain’t no Jesus/ Ain’t no God/ Wasting time on a creepy fraud, to the tune of “Jesus Loves Me.” Remember that? Throwing hymnals through my drum set? I forgive you. But I never got pregnant by the resource officer (I’m talking to you, Brandy Simon! Hey, girl!) so I consider myself somewhat of a behavioral blue ribbon. I also learned a lot, like the definition of “frigid.” But mostly, I learned about myself.
As most of you know, I wasn’t exactly prom king Troy Bolton at Smoky Mountain High School, but you generally knew who I was—it was to hard to miss a girl with three dreadlocks tied in knots on the top of her head, wasn’t it? And even though I frequently ate my vegan bologna sandos while dodging the tater tots landing atop my head (Hey, Dan Stevens! How’s the wife? She left you? Oops. My bad.), I like to think of Smoky Mountain High as a place of backwoods enlightenment. We didn’t have a gay/straight alliance or a PFLAG chapter, but we did have a show choir, which is basically the same thing. There were a few less progressive school traditions, like Christian Heritage Week—five days around that big Jesus holiday in April when the student president of Christians for a United National Theocracy (CUNT) read a prayer or fun fact about Christianity (i.e. Jesus said brown people like their chains!) during morning announcements, which, much to the regret of my inner cheerleader, quickly ceased after my parents called the ACLU. (So sorry, Annie Tops. I know you loved speaking into that mic.)
But the really incredible thing about Smoky Mountain High was that you, my classmates, knew me before I knew myself. Whether I was shooting free throws in my Umbros or auditioning for the sophomore musical with an acapella version of “My Lover”, you guys were always trying to break down that closet door for me. Unlike you, I had no idea that I was lesbanese until college, when I had the light bulb realization that I was junk-struck for Catherine Keener while watching Being John Malkcovich with my first and only boyfriend, who later changed his name to Christy and bought a wonderful set of mammaries. This first love also indicated that I’m into power suits and somewhat of a bottom, but it took a few more years for that memo to penetrate the gray matter.
There I was, happily living as a high school Heather Mattarazo with my posse of weed-smoking, softball-playing, ani-loving friends; discussing that Tracy Chapman song about rape on the Boys Don’t Cry soundtrack and wondering why none of the guys in Students Teaching AIDS Research (STAR) ever asked us out. It was a total mystery—not just that the Vice President of STAR who waxed his eyebrows never called me back (Congrats on the Asian babies, Donnie Nickels! And those abs!), but all of it…. Why did you call me a dyke, Jamie Taylor, when I held my best friend’s hand on the way to Algebra II? We were best friends. It’s not like we played footsie under the cafeteria table that often.
But now—inevitably and undeniably gayelle at 28 physical and 19 emotional years old—I want to publically thank Joe Hart, Kyle Ross, Thomas Blakley Jr., and everyone else who saw beneath my bio-ween-loving facade. You knew that the only thing keeping romantic fulfillment beyond my unmanicured fingertips was a lack of self-awareness. It was you, Megan Overton, and you, Anne Nelson, and you, Bitsy Matthews—with your homophobic slurs and your poofy bangs and short shorts—who forced me to see the truth. You made me look into my heart and my erogenous zones (Neck and ears by the way. And who doesn’t love a good back rub?) to see the truth, the truthiest truth, that I am not like you, Jenny McDonald. I didn’t actually want to go the prom with you, Dylan Hendrix. I didn’t want to make-out the in the back your parent’s Corrolla, Alex Knight, and was relieved to find that stick-shift really gets in the way of heaving petting. No, what I wanted was Catherine Keener. Catherine Keener and blanket space at Lilith Fair and the knowledge that I, a womyn-loving-woman, could return to my alma mater one day. Return to you, with your dead marriages and the children that you don’t really love, hand-in-hand with my beautiful partner whose name happens to also be Katie, and thank you, Smoky Mountain High Class of 2000, for making all of this possible.



